Raising your rate is rarely a numbers problem. It is a positioning problem wearing a spreadsheet as a disguise.

Some links in this post are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Entrepreneurial Truth may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Most founders who are undercharging already know it. They've done the math. They know what their time costs, what their tools cost, and what the person down the street charges. The spreadsheet isn't the hard part.

The hard part is the sentence they'd have to say to a client. "Starting next month, my rate is going up." And behind that sentence is a quieter question: do I believe what I do is worth more?

That's why pricing work is quiet. Most of it happens before anyone sees a new number.

The number that stopped moving

Colin Ellsworth works with small businesses on operations and cash flow, and he hears the same thing all the time. Clients tell him, "This is what I do and this is what it's worth." His response is a question about groceries:

"How much has your own individual grocery bill gone up for the same amount of groceries? And then, have you charged your clients more in that same time frame?" (Watch at 20:32)

The price they're defending was right once. "The last time you looked at it, you were bang on the money," he said, "but now we're five, six, seven years past that." (Watch at 21:09)

The math changed. The way they saw their own work didn't. That's a positioning problem, not a numbers problem.

"Nobody pays the same amount"

The belief that keeps a lot of small businesses stuck is that a fair price means one price, for everyone, forever. Colin called this out directly:

"Let me introduce you to one of the biggest secrets in the corporate world. Nobody pays the same amount, right? Everybody pays something different. The only thing that's the same is the service that you get." (Watch at 22:06)

His fix is the gentlest rate increase you'll ever make. If you've charged $50 to plant a row of flowers for ten years, keep charging your current clients $50. "But all your new clients, go ahead and charge them 75." (Watch at 22:47)

Nobody gets a scary letter, and your loyal clients are protected. Your new price shows up where it should: with people meeting you for the first time, who see you as you are now, not as you were in 2017.

He's just as clear about the line you shouldn't cross. Pass along real cost increases, but don't use a scary market to "gouge your potential clients." (Watch at 30:29) Raising prices because your work is worth more is positioning. Raising them because people are nervous is something else.

The fear is about the customer leaving

Hima Priya coaches e-commerce founders, and she sees the same freeze from the other side of the counter:

"When I tell my clients to increase the price, the immediate thing is, oh no, if I increase the price, the customers will go. So they have that, and they are sticking to the old price by selling in loss." (Watch at 29:20)

Notice what her clients are afraid of. Not the math. They're afraid of being judged for the change.

Her process starts with the story, not the price. She looks at what competitors charge, settles on a target, and then sends emails to existing customers "before increasing the price in a nurturing kind of way, telling their customers like how they are different, why they are different." (Watch at 28:34) Then she raises it in steps over about a year, because "a sudden jump or doubling the price would not work." (Watch at 28:59)

And for anything high-ticket, the work is the same, just louder: "We have to highlight why it's so pricey… why it's so different from the competitors selling at a lower price." (Watch at 30:10)

Explaining why you're different is positioning. She does it before the price changes, not after.

Two approaches, one lesson

Colin and Hima would raise prices differently. Colin protects existing clients and moves the new price to new ones. Hima moves everyone up gradually, with a story first. Both work, depending on your business and your relationships.

What they agree on is the order. You don't start with the number. You start with how your customer understands what they're buying.

The quiet work, step by step

  1. Write down when you last changed your rate. If it's been more than a couple of years, Colin's grocery test applies to you.
  2. Write the "why we're different" paragraph. Before any new number, describe in plain words what a client gets from you that they won't get from the cheaper option. If you can't write it, that's the real job, and no spreadsheet will do it for you.
  3. Choose your path. New-clients-only (Colin) or a gradual step-up with a heads-up email (Hima). Pick the one you'll actually follow through on.
  4. Put the new price somewhere visible first. Your website, your proposals, your booking page. New prospects should only ever see the current rate.
  5. Track who pays what. If you go with Colin's approach, you'll have more than one rate for a while. A simple client table showing each client's rate and the date it last changed keeps it honest. A spreadsheet works. If you already run client records in Airtable, add the two fields there.
  6. Say the sentence out loud before you send it. It's quiet work, but at some point it has to be said. Practice it until it sounds like a fact, not an apology.

The disguise

A spreadsheet feels safer than a conversation about your worth. You can keep refining the numbers forever and never have to say anything. That's the disguise.

The founders who raise their rates well do the quiet part first: they get clear on what they offer, who it's for, and why it's different. After that, the new number is just a number.

Want a second set of eyes on your offer?

Pricing is where offer, positioning, and follow-up meet. If your quotes, proposals, and follow-up still show your old prices (or never follow up at all), Systems & AI can help. Book a free assessment. We'll look at how your offer is presented and followed up, then set up the system that delivers your new price consistently.

Listen to the conversations

New founder conversations every week: subscribe on YouTube · all episodes

Quotes are lightly trimmed for readability (… marks cuts).